Employee gets called out for agreeing to give a reference for former manager, then giving a bad yet honest review to the hiring manager: ‘You should have declined’
<div class="ck-content"><h2>Are you always expected to say good things when giving a reference for someone?</h2><p>When interviewing for a new job, one of the most hated stages is when you're asked to provide references. This means that you either have to dig up numbers of old coworkers and bosses who would be willing to say nice things about you, or find someone in your current workplace who can talk you up and wouldn't tell anyone else about your search for a new job. It is generally a taxing mission.</p><p>We've never been asked to be a reference for someone else, but we imagine that if someone asked us, we would want to be as honest as possible, which is easier said than done. Of course, you want to <a href="https://cheezburger.com/46412293/relentless-coworker-demands-employee-move-out-of-her-seat-in-break-room-despite-knowing-there-are-no" target="_blank" rel="noopener">give your honest feedback</a> about what it was like to work with someone, but if your experience with that person was not positive, being honest about it can ruin their job prospects, and that is a heavy burden to carry.</p><p>But what should you do instead? Lie? Let a workplace hire someone based on a false recommendation? That doesn't sound very fair either.</p><p>The best solution to this issue is to simply not give the reference in the first place. If someone you didn't enjoy working with asks to put you down as a reference for a potential job, the kindest thing you can do for them is decline. You will obviously have to explain yourself and be honest with them about why you can't give a good reference, but it's better that they know and work on it than for you to hold it in.</p><p>Unfortunately, that is not the route <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/AITAH/comments/1vm0o7b/aitah_for_giving_my_former_manager_a_bad/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">u/sirthevinegar</a> took…</p></div>